Skip to content

Casting Suggestions For The Apparent Remake of The Dirty Dozen

Every so often news of a remake splashes the headlines of some Hollywood trade paper and most recently Variety had a news break that David Ayer has been hired by Warner Brothers to write and direct a modern day version of the 1967 classic. It should be noted that MGM released the original so I guess the story rights have since changed hands. Having already written and directed 2014’s WW2 carnage, Fury, perhaps he’s the man for the job. Anyone notice that film carried plenty of similarities to Peckinpah’s The Wild Bunch?

Now when it comes to The Dirty Dozen I’d want a say in the casting ideas. Why? Cause alongside a 1975 movie about a big fish it’s my all-time favorite film going back to seeing it as a kid on TV. Lost track of just how many times I’ve seen it but I dare say it has to be over 50 viewings. These days I’m down to about 1 viewing a year but when I was a kid and the VHS rental age was upon us …. well you get the idea.

One could argue that The Dozen has already been remade with TV sequels of it’s own in the late 1980’s but I’ve always felt it’s served as an inspiration to countless films ranging from 1972’s Massacre at Ft. Holman to Tarantino’s Inglorious Basterds. Having a great love for the original I’ve already featured the film twice here at Mike’s Take. Once to  spotlight the 1967 Press Booklet and the other time on a live take to chat about the film.

Now let’s get on with my casting suggestions.

First and foremost we need a leading man to take on Lee Marvin’s duties as the rebellious, not quite by the book yet tough minded Major running the operation. Attempting to stay away from the aging Expendables cast I’ve settled on Woody Harrelson. If he’s not available then I’d ring up Daniel Craig’s agent since his days of playing Bond are apparently over.

Behind Marvin were three members of the military brass pulling the strings on the operation. Generals Ernest Borgnine and Robert Webber accompanied by George Kennedy’s Major in what are essentially elongated cameos.

How about a stern Kurt Russell taking on Borgnine’s General, Paul Giamatti as Kennedy’s Major and Sean Bean as the sour faced General that Webber played who isn’t in favor of the mission to begin with.

Now while the Germans were the actual enemy in the original movie you wouldn’t know it till the final hour because it’s Robert Ryan’s Colonel who abhors Lee Marvin’s tactics and wants to “make it my business to run you right out of this man’s army.” So for that role I’ve selected Gary Oldman.

Something that is overlooked when recalling the original is the humor involved. Some of that comes to the forefront when psychiatrist Ralph Meeker interviews members of the dozen. How about William H. Macy conducting the exams?

When Marvin leads the Dozen oversees to the explosive finale he brings along his faithful sergeant to aid in the attack played by one of my favorite character actors, Richard Jaeckel. Why not cast Ryan Gosling as the man who coins the phrase “Dirty Dozen.”

And now the Dirty Dozen themselves. It should be noted that when the original film went into production 6 “name” actors were cast to play the majority of the scenes involving the GI convicts and 6 “no-names” to flesh out the 12 men needed for the film. Of the 6 who were primarily relegated to the background, only one, Donald Sutherland, went on to having a major career. So I’ll stick to 7 suggestions matching our well known members of the The Dirty Dozen.

First up, John Cassavetes, played Victor Franco. The loose cannon of the group with a rebellious streak. Comically I might suggest James Franco but would much rather see Ben Foster in the role.

Not surprisingly, Charles Bronson, played a rugged member of the dozen who Marvin could count on to get the job done once the action got underway. To me this one’s easy. Josh Brolin has that same look about him that Bronson carried in his prime.

Jim Brown retired from football while The Dirty Dozen was in production and since I’m not aware of any football players who might fit the role of Jefferson I’ll go with Jamie Foxx cause frankly, I’d love to see him on screen trading jabs with a cast like the one I’m recommending.

The biggest man of the original Dozen was Clint Walker. A real giant who towered over many a co-star. Would Dwayne Johnson take on the role? He’s the obvious choice for my money.

Telly Savalas scored the memorable role of Archer Maggott. A psychotic rapist/killer who is clearly the most dangerous member of the dozen. I kind of like the work Jon Bernthal has been doing and think he’d be a good fit.

Film goers of ’67 might have been surprised to see singer Trini Lopez as the meekest member of the Dozen. No need to cast a singer but I will suggest Daniel Radcliffe for the part as he continues his journey from the world of Harry Potter into adult roles.

Donald Sutherland lucked into the memorable role of Vernon Pinkley when director Robert Aldrich needed someone to play the scene of a phony General after Clint Walker didn’t think it matched his character. Supposedly Aldrich pointed to the unknown Sutherland and said “you with the big ears.” and the rest is history. My vote goes to Michael Shannon for the part.

To be fair, the other five actors who were featured as members of the original Dirty Dozen were Tom Busby, Colin Maitland, Stuart Cooper, Ben Carruthers and Al Mancini. Each had a scene or two but for whatever reason never had their acting careers take off as did Sutherland’s.

Ask me to redo this list tomorrow and I might go a different direction. Bring in Matt Damon in the Lee Marvin role. I can see that or bow to producers and offer the role to Tom Cruise? Did you know John Wayne was the first actor approached to play the Major in the original? Had he starred I suggest it might have been a much different film. Instead Duke settled on The Green Berets. Other names that I could see squeezing into the Dozen are Mark Wahlberg, John Leguizamo, Ryan Reynolds, Tom Hiddleston or how about Tom Hardy in the Bronson role?

And getting back to those Generals in the war room. Easy to swap out my choices for the likes of Kevin Costner, Harrison Ford and John Travolta.

I suspect the cast I’ve come up with might be a bit costly so I’m not to sure if any of my choices will be seriously considered. Then of course the word EGO might come rear it’s ugly head among these gents.

I’ll turn it over to you now. Any likes among my selections? Any strong dislikes? Care to come up with some ideas of your own and share? I’d love to hear what you have to say as would others who have dropped in to have a look. Hopefully if and when the new version hits movie screens they put out a movie poster that draws on the originals artwork.

12 Comments »

  1. Not a bad list, but I don’t see Woody Harrelson playing Riesman, he’s played military types before I know, but Riesman is a gruff, tough SOB, and Harrelson just isn’t that. I would say Harrison Ford, Bruce Willis, or Sam Elliot would better fit the bill there.

    • Thanks for the suggestions. I can see Bruce in the role but feel the other two are finally too old for the role. I had thought of Tommy lee Jones as well but again, feel he’s too old though again I can see all of those guys as the military brass at HQ. On Woody it was a case of the more I thought about it the more I think it could work. He’s got that bad boy rep that Lee had and I think can play it tough when called upon. Cheers’.

    • You’ll have to see Woody in that War For The Planet of the Apes flick from a few years ago. He’s perfectly mean and unhinged, although he gets a pretty cruel fate thanks to it, lol. That;s a neat list of potentials, Mike. Hopefully, the studio can afford all those stars!

      • I did see Woody in that and he was impressive. On the cost involved, we could up it by adding Robert Downey Jr. in there somehow as I can see him fitting in to a variety of slots. Colin Farrell as well.

  2. Any discussion of a remake of THE DIRTY DOZEN has to mention THE EXPENDABLES series so i’m glad you to gave the nod to that.
    Jamie Fox and Josh Brolin are both inspired choices.

  3. The reality is Mike how ever incredible your choices are the true fact is that it’s more likely to be Sandra Bullock, Leslie Jones and Tina Fey (who’s in everything). Probably Kevin Hart will be considered for comic relief.
    Obviously I’m only “half” joking.
    If they need to put a couple of ladies in there I’ll be rooting for Michelle Rodriguez and Gina Carano.
    Maybe The Rock would over shadow the whole project! I might replace him for Dave Bautista.
    Absolutely brilliant article Mike. Loved reading that with my egg and soldiers this morning.

    • I see our taste in the ladies continues to stay similar. I thought of this slant but wanted to stay true to the original but yes I love to watch both those gals kicking ass. If budget restraints kick in I’m sure Bautista can fill in for the Rock for lesser pay. Maybe like the original they’ll film it in England which leads to me to suggest you should do a little research on the original locations and see if anything is still standing. Make for a good article.

  4. First, let me get this out there: I hope somebody DOESN’T remake it, because they’ll only screw it up…imagine if someone tried to remake that fish movie from the mid-70s. Ugh! Anyway, quite the eclectic list of actors there…I don’t know if I would’ve thought of any of them! First, I was trying to come up with ANYone who could fill the shoes (and clothes) of Clint Walker, and size-wise, Johnson seems to make sense…but I don’t think he has the right personality. Beyond that, I’m stumped, although I did think of Colin Farrell playing one of the dozen as well.

    And since Wolfman stole my joke of having an all-female dozen (The Flirty Dozen?), how about I throw in…a dozen made up entirely of CHILDREN! And it’ll be rated ‘G’! Yeah, I think it’ll work!

    • I’m in total agreement but Hollywood loves to recycle anything that has the potential to turn a profit. Might be inevitable. So many names I thought of and Farrell was one as was Sam Rockwell. Think he’d make a good member of the dozen. As for the ladies I have some definite names to add to wish list and Salma Hayek is tops. They did make the cartoon Toy Soldiers for the kiddies years back that in itself was a nod to the Dozen with plenty of voice work from surviving members at that time.

Leave a Reply to Glen available Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

LOST IN SPACE FIRESIDE

A Galaxy of Rewind

Lazarus' Lair

NOT Just another WordPress.com weblog

"DESTROY ALL FANBOYS!"

Smashing System Bias Since 1972...

Movies ala Mark

With a Cast of Thousands

Classic Horrors

From silent screen to Halloween, and everything scary in between.

Just Hit Play

The Good, the Bad and sometimes Ugly in film

Strother Martin Film Project

What we've got here is failure to communicate

Sophia Riley Kobacker

it's all about the story, possums...

Wolfmans Cult Film

Cult, B-Movies, cheesy fun films to Film Noir to classics new to me.

Talking Pulp

All things pulp and then some

cinema cities

a personal odyssey through film

Mark David Welsh

Feeding Soda Pop to the Thirsty Pigs since 2013

Film Speech

All things film and television

Diary of A Movie Maniac

A Personal Journey Through Cinema & Television

portraitsbyjenni

My perspective on life & Classic Movie Recommendations

Statis Pro 1978 Replay

Methodically replaying every game of the 1978 baseball season!

4 Star Films

Looking Deeper at The Best Classic Movies Together

everythingnoir

Movies, Television, Books....Everything Noir

Chaplin-Keaton-Lloyd film locations (and more)

by John Bengtson "the great detective of silent film locations" New York Times

Sister Celluloid

Where old movies go to live

Silent-ology

Uncovering the silent era

Noirish

The annex to John Grant's *A Comprehensive Encyclopedia of Film Noir*

Cinema Monolith

Reviews of movies from my giant DVD tower, and more.

Sunset Boulevard

Writings of a Cinephile

The Bogie Film Blog

A Film by Film Affair with Humphrey Bogart

Vienna's Classic Hollywood

Vintage Hollywood films and stars

film-authority.com

Talking movies...

Once upon a screen...

...a classic film and TV blog

shadowsandsatin

. . where the worlds of film noir and pre-code collide . .

Alfred Hitchcock Master

Where Suspense Lives!

Tipping My Fedora

Enjoying mystery, crime and suspense in all media

Silver Screenings

Ruth's Old Movie Reviews

monsterminions

They Don't Make 'Em Like They Used To

Comet Over Hollywood

Home for classic movie lovers

filmgeek101

classic movie views for the classic and not-so-classic movie fan

Riding the High Country

Reviews and ramblings

LOST IN SPACE FIRESIDE

A Galaxy of Rewind

Lazarus' Lair

NOT Just another WordPress.com weblog

"DESTROY ALL FANBOYS!"

Smashing System Bias Since 1972...

Movies ala Mark

With a Cast of Thousands

Classic Horrors

From silent screen to Halloween, and everything scary in between.

Just Hit Play

The Good, the Bad and sometimes Ugly in film

Strother Martin Film Project

What we've got here is failure to communicate

Sophia Riley Kobacker

it's all about the story, possums...

Wolfmans Cult Film

Cult, B-Movies, cheesy fun films to Film Noir to classics new to me.

Talking Pulp

All things pulp and then some

cinema cities

a personal odyssey through film

Mark David Welsh

Feeding Soda Pop to the Thirsty Pigs since 2013

Film Speech

All things film and television

Diary of A Movie Maniac

A Personal Journey Through Cinema & Television

portraitsbyjenni

My perspective on life & Classic Movie Recommendations

Statis Pro 1978 Replay

Methodically replaying every game of the 1978 baseball season!

4 Star Films

Looking Deeper at The Best Classic Movies Together

everythingnoir

Movies, Television, Books....Everything Noir

Chaplin-Keaton-Lloyd film locations (and more)

by John Bengtson "the great detective of silent film locations" New York Times

Sister Celluloid

Where old movies go to live

Silent-ology

Uncovering the silent era

Noirish

The annex to John Grant's *A Comprehensive Encyclopedia of Film Noir*

Cinema Monolith

Reviews of movies from my giant DVD tower, and more.

Sunset Boulevard

Writings of a Cinephile

The Bogie Film Blog

A Film by Film Affair with Humphrey Bogart

Vienna's Classic Hollywood

Vintage Hollywood films and stars

film-authority.com

Talking movies...

Once upon a screen...

...a classic film and TV blog

shadowsandsatin

. . where the worlds of film noir and pre-code collide . .

Alfred Hitchcock Master

Where Suspense Lives!

Tipping My Fedora

Enjoying mystery, crime and suspense in all media

Silver Screenings

Ruth's Old Movie Reviews

monsterminions

They Don't Make 'Em Like They Used To

Comet Over Hollywood

Home for classic movie lovers

filmgeek101

classic movie views for the classic and not-so-classic movie fan

Riding the High Country

Reviews and ramblings

Speakeasy

movies galore

%d bloggers like this: